Posted: 20 January 2010 at 11:01am | IP Logged | 6
|
|
|
As I have said before, if you're dealing with an audience that changesevery few years, as used to be the case, Tony building his outer spacearmor, or his undersea armor, or hisarmor-Robin-wears-when-Batman-is-injured almost works. But if you'redealing with the modern (by which I mean the past 30 years or so)audience, that sticks around for decades, it makes no sense at all tosuddenly say the armor that has been seen comfortably flying thru spaceor cruising at crushing ocean depths needs to be "modified" or evenreplaced for those "special" assignments.A rose is a rose. Iron Man is Iron Man.* * * * * * Have to say I can't disagree more. If your catering to 30+ year fans you're in deep trouble. Especially with science fiction where the once futuristic can often look extremely quaint as our view of the future changes, because sometimes the technology we think is right around the corner ends up being far more complicated than we could imagine and we dial our expectations down.... where are our flying cars and jetpacks? Oh, right, those are completely impractical... nevermind. Take the original Star Trek. It was created at a time in which computers were mysterious things that had flashing lights and gave read-outs that only trained technicians could read. So they come up with a sleeker version of then-modern computers. •• First, try reading what I wrote, not what you want to think I wrote. I am not talking about "predictive" technology. Stan had Iron Man's armor powered by transistors, which was not even accurate technology for the time! But the idea behind the technology in comics is not to be predictive, but merely to be beyond what we have at the time. (When I joined the Industry, it was common to say the technology was at least fifteen to 20 years ahead of what we had. Not in a predictive sense, but in an isn't-that-cool sense.) Thus, even Iron Man's clunky gray armor was far ahead of anything that could actually be made in the 1960s. The "specialized" suits reverse this, and do, indeed, attempt to be predictive. Read the OHOTMU entry for Iron Man and find it full to bursting with "real world" science. Cold fusion was in the headlines when the entry was written, so Stark's suit becomes powered by cold fusion. This is pandering the the thirty-somethings, who cannot accept the "Because It Does" answer to how something works. These are the ones who want to know what kind of spider bit Peter Parker, or where the Thing's fourth finger disappeared to. And those are NOT the people we should be playing to, but the "specialized" suits do exactly that. Elsewhere, apparently you were watching STAR TREK beamed in from some parallel universe, since the computer tech I saw on TOS was not only surprisingly predictive, it did not require trained technicians to work it. Only the ability to say "Computer on".
|