••

And they're wrong.

There is not an iota of reliable evidence supporting the ACTUAL existence of "psychic abilities" in the real world. People have spent THOUSANDS of years trying to prove they exist, without success. While the rest of Nature has slowly been revealed, while real, measurable reasons for so much that used to be considered "magic" have been uncovered, "psychic powers" remain completely imaginary.

This is not about a "point of view".

To me, Watchmen was never about the mystery of who killed the Comedian. It was about the journey of discovering who the characters were/are. Your milage may vary on how well you enjoyed that aspect of the book, however, I think it works well as a self contained story.

Before Watchmen seems to be a series of mini-series that just expands on an already told story. Moore/Gibbons laid out everything you needed to know about the characters in the 12 issues of Watchmen and did so in a concise way. I am very skeptical that they will cover any new ground in these new mini-series and instead just naval-gaze upon what we already know. It seems DC has missed the point of what Watchmen was about if all they do is expand on backstories that were already told.

Having said that, the art teams alone have me interested in reading these books. Adam Hughes, Jae Lee, Lee Bermejo, JG Jones, Adam/Joe Kubert, Amanda Connor and Darwyn Cooke are some mighty talented artists. These will be some wonderfully drawn books at the very least. I'm hoping DC surprises me with something different, but I highly doubt they will.

Well, as to the topic title, the worst comic I've ever read that you couldn't pay me to read again: Jeph Loeb's ULTIMATUM.

Re. Pre-Watchman.  I'll for certain buy Cooke's MINUTEMEN book to support Cooke.  If the art is really good for Comedian and Rorschach books I'll at least try them out. 

I have no objection to the pre-Watchmen projects.  I just hope they are worth all the hot fuss people are making.

I was a Watchmen fan in the 10th grade (88-89) when I read it. I gradually grew tired of it when fans declared that it was superior to regular comic books that I enjoyed. Sure it was a good read but I preferred JB's Fantastic Four, Claremont's X-Men, Stern's Avengers, and Simonson's Thor to Watchmen. Other than that Moore's writing doesn't appeal to me.

As far as the WSJ article goes, I don't disagree with much of it. The tone may have been harsh but it's interesting how he calls out Joe Q, Bendis, DIdio, and Grant Morrison by name. Those are four guys that I blame for much of what has changed (as far as my tastes go) in comics. Quesada tried his best to be the Howard Stern of comics with Bill Jemas and as far as I'm concerned really has done more bad than good at Marvel. Bendis has far too much control of the current Marvel characters and they all read the same way to me. His characters feel like "I think it would be cool if Hawkeye would do this even though it's not in character, it'll make my story better". Didio's reign at DC has darkened their comics, it seems that death and other dark elements are more important to him than a good story. I can read  Morrison at times but more often than not I just have a puzzeled look on my face after I read one of his stories. I personally would throw Mark Millar and his fascinations with anti-heroes and rape into the mix.  

Loeb seems to borrow a page from the Millar handbook these days: Over the Top Everything Shock Value. I could never picture Millar writing the kind of stuff that Loeb has done with Tim Sale so Loeb at least has the ability to write good comics.

I've raised the question before, without seeing a satisfactory answer: has Moore actually created anything that was entirely his own? Not being snarky here, I promise. (After all, I make no claims to being Captain Originality!)
____________________________________

Well, he wrote The Ballad of Halo Jones for 2000AD (and that wasn't based on preexisting characters or anything).

D.R. & Quinch for 2000AD (wasn't based on preexisting characters either), the same happens with Skizz for 2000AD.

He also wrote TOP TEN (another original creation).

And he has written many  Tharg's Future Shocks or Time Twisters that would count as original works.