***

Can't really think of any scenes that truly fit the terminology, aside from those I name, so fuel adding would be extremely difficult without practising the same kind of myopia this "Zan" seems to have made a lifestyle. Note his/her choices -- the Big Barda story in ACTION, neglecting to note that Superman receives the same treatment. The abuse of Artemis in Hell, sidestepping the fact that she was there in the first place looking for Harry Matthews. And, please. Jasmine's abortion? Where does that fit?

The rest, a parade of female characters being swatted out of the air, or knocked aside by bad guys, match in all details the treatment meted out to the male characters since the genre was invented. It would seem that the agenda here is to single out any act of violence of which a woman is on the receiving end as being distinctly different from the same act of violence perpetrated against a man. The word "sexist" springs to mind.

+++

By the way, "Zan" seems to credit you for inventing the image of one character holding up another character by the throat.  He/she refers to this action as a Byrne Hold.  Is he/she quoting something, or was that attribution created in this article?  (I'm pretty sure that there were, y'know, like, other artists who drew such images before you became a professional.  Just a hunch.)

***

****

You know the answer to that one, Matt. At some point in the last fifteen years or so, as the marketplace has shrunk and thus come more and more under the control of the basement dwellers who are still mad at me for quitting UNCANNY X-MEN back in 1980, I have become the Great Satan. Dissing me and my work has become the shorthand for being "inside" and "cool" with that unfortunately large contingent of fandom who are not troubled by such niceties as truth or accuracy.

***

Not answering for Matt here, but your question underscores the basic problem with essays like this. One could take the works of Alan Moore, or Stan Lee, Chris Claremont, or Roger Stern, or Frank Miller, or Walt Simonson, or Denny O'Neil, or, frankly, just about any writer of super hero stories you would care to mention, and in them find women being treated in precisely the same way as they are in mine. In fact, in some of the older stories -- Sue Storm, Lois Lane Girl Hostages -- you will find the "abuse" is really the only purpose the female characters have. They exist to be kidnapped by the badguys and rescued by the heroes.