Active Topics | Member List | Search | Help | Register | Login
Music
Byrne Robotics > Music
Topic: When is a group not a group Post ReplyPost New Topic
Author
Message
James Woodcock
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 21 September 2007
Location: United Kingdom
Posts: 4708
Posted: 12 November 2018 at 8:14am | IP Logged | 1 post reply

DEAD CAN DANCE have released a new album. However, it turns out that the majority of the album was written by one member and Lisa Gerrard only sings on a couple of tracks.

This is causing much uproar among DCD fans as they are calling it a Brendan Parry album and not a DCD album.

So, in similar vein, what are people's thoughts on this area?
Back to Top profile | search e-mail
 
Mario Ribeiro
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 18 June 2016
Location: Brazil
Posts: 306
Posted: 12 November 2018 at 8:48am | IP Logged | 2 post reply

The Final Cut was credited as a Roger Waters album performed by Pink Floyd.
Back to Top profile | search
 
Bill Collins
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 26 May 2005
Location: England
Posts: 10414
Posted: 12 November 2018 at 9:13am | IP Logged | 3 post reply

It`s a tricky one! Remember Trigger`s broom in Only
Fools and Horses? He claimed to have used the same
broom in his job for numerous years, despite changing
the head and handle a fair few times! Is Queen still
Queen, without Freddie Mercury? (I say no, as he had a
distinct voice and writing style) I recall a Tony
Iommi solo album being released under the Black
Sabbath banner as it was thought by the record company
that it would sell better.I think that if there`s a
definitive, recognisable songwriter and/or vocalist
that the group wouldn`t sound the same without, then
they ought to release under a different name.Jeff
Lynne and ELO, springs to mind, he wrote and recorded
their best material and sang on it, basically, he IS
ELO.But some older groups have members leave, to the
point where there is only one original member, it`s
not the group you fell in love with then is it?Of
course, as i mentioned earlier, it all comes down to
business decisions in the end!

Edited by Bill Collins on 12 November 2018 at 9:14am
Back to Top profile | search e-mail
 
Peter Martin
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 17 March 2008
Location: Canada
Posts: 11171
Posted: 12 November 2018 at 1:19pm | IP Logged | 4 post reply

Certainly agree it's a tricky one. A distinctive change in the songwriter/vocalist doesn't necessarily make a new group, to my mind. For example, adding Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham to Fleetwood Mac inarguably changed the fundamentals of the group, not just the sound, but the nationality of the members. But I don't think we can argue that the Fleetwood Mac with Nicks and Buckingham isn't the real Fleetwood Mac.

Ditto Genesis without Peter Gabriel. A different era of the group certainly and different sound, but not a new group.

It seems to come down more to whether the new version of the group establishes itself with new music. Queen + guest vocalist seems like a pseudo version of the group because, as you say, Freddie was so distinctive, but it doesn't help that they left such a big gap after Freddie died and have not had a proper hit without Freddie.

There's something instinctive or intuitive  that goes on as to whether something feels it's the real deal or not.

There is an album from 2012 called That's Why God Made The Radio by 'The Beach Boys'. It was produced by Brian Wilson. Brian Wilson co-wrote a lot of the songs. The group is as close to authentic as was possible. Brian, Mike Love, Al Jardine are all founder members. Bruce Johnston was a Beach Boy since the mid 60s. David Marks sang and played on four early albums. But there was no Carl or Dennis, of course. And the album didn't feel like it was genuinely the Beach Boys; more a thing driven by Capitol Records. Hard to objectively say why it feels a bit pseudo. Certainly more genuine than anything since 1985, but without Carl and Dennis it's like the heart and soul of the band are missing. And then there's just that thing called time.




Edited by Peter Martin on 12 November 2018 at 1:20pm
Back to Top profile | search
 
Bill Collins
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 26 May 2005
Location: England
Posts: 10414
Posted: 14 November 2018 at 10:49am | IP Logged | 5 post reply

I agree with Peter, the addition of a member to replace
someone, can lead to greater success, yet it`s still
fundamentally the same group, even though they may
change sound/style like Genesis with Gabriel/Collins,
Sabbath with Ozzy/Dio, Iron Maiden with
DiAnno/Dickinson.
Rush replacing their drummer John Rutsey with Neil Peart
was a definitive game changer for them in both lyrics
and musical progression.
I guess it depends on how many original members you can
replace, before hey may as well be a tribute band.
Back to Top profile | search e-mail
 
Robbie Parry
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 17 June 2007
Location: United Kingdom
Posts: 12187
Posted: 14 November 2018 at 4:33pm | IP Logged | 6 post reply

As Bill knows, it was never the same when Craig Logan left Bros!
Back to Top profile | search
 
Brian Floyd
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 07 July 2006
Location: United States
Posts: 6127
Posted: 14 November 2018 at 7:43pm | IP Logged | 7 post reply

The current version of Foreigner that's touring is really Mick Jones with a bunch of other musicians, if I remember right.

I forget which album it's on, but Def Leppard's cover of "Space Oddity" is really Joe Elliott solo.

(And, probably doesn't count, but Journey became dead to me when they fired Steve Perry.)


Back to Top profile | search e-mail
 
Peter Martin
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 17 March 2008
Location: Canada
Posts: 11171
Posted: 14 November 2018 at 10:16pm | IP Logged | 8 post reply

As Bill knows, it was never the same when Craig Logan left Bros
--------------------------------
Strangely, this is very true. Kind of difficult to judge, I suppose, as it's a big span from one album to the next when a band is such a flash in the pan. Still, Too Much was a big hit for them. But, as you say, there was an 80s-fretless-bass-player-shaped hole missing by that point. Acting as a vampire in a Marvel film is the only natural next step if you are the drummer in such circumstances.
Back to Top profile | search
 
Bill Collins
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 26 May 2005
Location: England
Posts: 10414
Posted: 15 November 2018 at 1:11am | IP Logged | 9 post reply

"As Bill knows, it was never the same when Craig Logan
left Bros"

Yes, i was bereft at the time!
Didn`t he go on to greater success in management?

On a similar note, Nick Beggs, the bass player from
Kajagoogoo, is now one of the most respected bass
players in the Prog world.
Back to Top profile | search e-mail
 
Daniel Gillotte
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 11 October 2005
Location: United States
Posts: 1948
Posted: 04 December 2018 at 1:55pm | IP Logged | 10 post reply

Is Journey with the excellent karaoke singing front man still Journey?

Was Van Halen Van Halen when it was Van Hagar?

I think replacing front men is TOUGH. But a bass player or even a drummer or rhythm player is more do-able. (also Rhythm is hard to spell)
Back to Top profile | search | www
 
Brian Floyd
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 07 July 2006
Location: United States
Posts: 6127
Posted: 04 December 2018 at 3:19pm | IP Logged | 11 post reply

I like Van Halen with DLR or Hagar. Gary Cherone, as much as I liked Exterme, did not fit all all.

Journey, on the other hand, might as well have been Steve Perry's backing band. He stood out more than anyone else. And I'm glad he's back, releasing new music after all these years.


Back to Top profile | search e-mail
 
Michael Roberts
Byrne Robotics Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 2004
Location: United States
Posts: 12373
Posted: 04 December 2018 at 3:45pm | IP Logged | 12 post reply

What about the alternate universe Van Halen where Patty Smyth had agreed to replace David Lee Roth? Would that have been Van Halen?
Back to Top profile | search
 

If you wish to post a reply to this topic you must first login
If you are not already registered you must first register

  Post ReplyPost New Topic
Printable version Printable version

Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

 Active Topics | Member List | Search | Help | Register | Login