Posted: 30 March 2017 at 1:06am | IP Logged | 6
|
|
|
Update: I sent emails to Chris Claremont and Jim Shooter and got these replies:
Chris Claremont: "Chris here, Will -- yes, that is my hand-writing on the Page 1 border, regarding ading Phoenix to the character scrawl. As for why she never made it up there, at least as far as I can recall, there was ongoing discussion between me and John and the editor (s, because it actually involved 3 different people over time) about it. Roger (and John) weren't thrilled and I actually can't remember precisely how Jim felt. And of course, given how the Jean / Dark Phoenix arc ended, the entire subject became moot as of X-Men #137. Hope this helps. Best, csc!"
Jim Shooter: "Dear Will,
John Byrne wrote that note on the original art, which is why it appears on the color guide shot from the art. It's his lettering, no doubt.
I don't remember why his suggestion wasn't followed. Maybe Chris Claremont would remember. Or Roger Stern.
Be well,
Jim Shooter "
Anyone have Roger Stern's email / contact info?
BTW...JB...I think it's wonderful and I am thankful that you and other comic greats from back in the day are so easily accessible and willing to provide input to an old fan's obscure question! Thanks again!
-Will
|